After a short night with little sleep, I got on the plane looking forward to some quality down-time. I needed to make some huge, life-changing decisions by the end of the weekend, so I had spent some time journaling and praying. Little did I know that I was about to enter into an unprovoked-gift of a conversation.

The flight was relatively empty & everybody on the plane could have easily had their own aisle, so you can imagine my confusion when a guy moved right into my aisle. As he took his seat I considered that it may not be accidental that I would have a neighbor for the 2+ hour flight; though I am confident he would scoff at such an implication. Less than a minute went by before our incredibly un-cordial introduction.
Glancing at a book sitting next to me Paul, who’s name I wouldn’t learn for another hour-and-a-half, broke the short-lived silence. He turned to me with a furrow on his brow and said, “You can’t honestly take that God-Crap seriously”. Before I could even acknowledge the awkwardness of his introduction, I answered with emphatic affirmation that I do take God-Crap seriously.
The gist of his stance went like this: “You are staking your entire life on the fabricated, handed-down accounts from dead guys 2,000 years ago… and I only base my life off of what I know, as established through the proven reliability of the Scientific Method”. While I quickly acknowledged his superior intellect I was quickly established that it wasn’t my job to prove anything to my new friend.
To Paul’s disappointment, my faith in a Sovereign Creator (GOD) would not be so easily destroyed. While he recognized that my level of knowledge and commitment to reason was not as weak as he had anticipated, he was never satisfied with my answers and it became clear that his dilemma doesn’t lie in a lack of information. In the end, Paul asked for my best shot at giving a logical account for why I believe what I do, and my answer was this:
“I have personally experienced the omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent & omni-benevolent God of the Bible; through personal study of His inerrant Word and a very real drawing of my mind, heart, intellect, emotions…my soul. I have responded to Him with an appropriate & sincere faith that has been consistently established under the scrutiny of questioning from external sources, as well as internal doubts that have risen over the years. In the end, I have experienced God (in the all-encompassing sense of the term) in such a way that my belief has grown stronger and I can do no other than to respond with whole-hearted devotion and awe.
After a brief chuckle, and a recognition that my vernacular is a weird blend of Christian, Philosophic, Hip-hop banter (maybe my delivery came with a hip-hop tone), he simply said that I am basing my entire life on some very unstable premises. Paul said his goal was to hold up a mirror for me to see what shaky ground I am standing on. I sincerely thanked him for his concern and commitment to initiate such a conversation with a complete stranger, then I offered one last thought for him to leave with: “Paul, I can’t leave our 2 hour conversation without holding a mirror up before you”, and he finally stopped, somewhat shocked, and welcomed my challenge. ”I want you to realize that for some reason you come with presuppositions regarding the validity (or lack of) any person’s belief/faith in the God of the Bible, and you are unable to objectively discuss the topic. More importantly though, you have deemed yourself to be the final authority for what is truth, and you have chosen the scientific method as your gavel. From this, You are the god of the universe you interact with and you are waiting for answers that will satisfy your biased, final judgement”.
He graciously nodded his head and said that was fair, then, sadly, confirmed my charge throughout the rest of our conversation…and I am sure I did the same for him. He expressed a desire to hold a public debate in the Sacramento area with me and I will look forward to discussing this further. While his intelligence is far superior to mine, and there would be many better suitors for him, it is important for an ‘average follower of Jesus’ to discuss the grounds for his/her faith. As I close, I want to clearly state what I would love your feedback on. Please answer any or all of the following questions:
1.) Is one’s experience (in the broadest sense of the word) the final measure for what he/she accepts as truth.
2.) Please evaluate the best defense I offered for my faith, and give any feedback/thoughts/additions/etc. (It was pretty much off the cuff, but I desire to obey the biblical command to have a ready defense/explanation for one’s faith).
3.) What is your personal explanation for what you believe (or “don’t believe”… though I would want to discuss the implications of that)?
4.) How do you evaluate/land on truth?